Today I’m addressing the most common question about our quest for a VBAC: What are the risks and benefits of a VBAC vs a repeat cesarean? A little about this series: Our second baby is due at the end of April, and we are hoping and trying for a VBAC (vaginal birth after cesarean section). There are many reasons why we are heading this direction and I hope to share them with y’all over the next few months. You can read the other posts in my Trying for a VBAC series here. You can read the Bear’s full birth story here to see what our first child’s birth entailed. If you read that story you will get a little glimpse into why we are now on this journey to VBAC and a normal birth. This process has been all consuming for me and this blog is my space to express the way I feel about the whole situation. Many folks have strong opinions about VBAC vs. repeat cesarean, and I hope that whatever your opinion might be you will respect mine. VBAC is not the right decision for every c-mama, and it doesn’t always work out no matter how you prepare. Our hope and prayer is that we can have the best birth possible for our little girl. I am not in any way a medical professional, just a mama who loves nerding out over research.
Risks VS Benefits of a VBAC or Elective Repeat Cesarean Section
First lets look at the risks of both, lined up together. I’ll start with what I like to call the “Big Scaries”.
Big Scary #1: Risk of Baby Dying
VBAC – 0.2% vs C-Section (ERCS) – 0.1%
Both rates are very low, but slightly higher for VBAC.
Big Scary #2: Risk of Uterine Rupture
VBAC – 0.4% vs C-Section (ERCS) – 0.2%
Did you know you could have a rupture with an ERCS? I didn’t either. The next facts really shocked me. Let’s look at the risk of uterine rupture for 1st time moms in natural births vs those induced and augmented with pitocin and/or prostoglandins.
Natural, spontaneous labor – 0.012%
Spontaneous labor augmented (prostoglandins, pitocin, etc) – 0.9%
Induced Labor – 1% (WHAT???)
When I read those numbers from multiple scientific studies, I was seriously angry at my previous OB who mentioned none of the risks of induction. If you were induced or had augmentation during labor, did your OB mention the more than doubled risk of uterine rupture? I’d really like to know. I’ve asked a lot of mamas and across the board I’ve not heard of anyone being told this by their OB. Not cool.
Big Scary #3: Risk of Mom Dying
VBAC – 0.02% vs C-Section (ERCS) – 0.04%
Both rates are very low, but slightly higher for c-section. The problem is that this rate increases greatly with each repeat c-section, limiting the potential of family by putting mom at risk.
The other risks of VBAC are the same as normal first time birth, but many other risks increase greatly with a repeat c-section and continue to increase even more with a 3rd, 4th, etc c-section. I’ve found that most women are told the risks of VBAC I mentioned above but not the risks of repeat c-section. Why is this? Many birth professionals believe it because of 2 things: 1)the bad rap VBACs got during the 1990s when it was common to use drugs like Cytotec to induce labor, greatly increasing the risk of uterine rupture and 2)because a c-section is easier to control for the physician, takes less time, and makes more money. A VBAC or other vaginal birth costs around $3-5000 while a c-section costs upwards of $25,000 for the patient. I support every woman’s right to choose the birth that she feels is best for her baby and herself, but I believe we also have the right to know the risks and benefits of each choice.
Risks to Baby that Increase with Repeat C-Section:
being cut during the surgery
premature birth (and all the risks that come with that)
respiratory problems at birth and lifelong
readmission to hospital or NICU time
risk of death in first month of life
Type 1 Diabetes
Risks to Mom that Increase with Repeat C-Section:
unintended cuts or damage during the surgery
complications from anesthesia
depression and other negative psychological issues
future pregnancy issues including placenta previa, stillbirth, low birth weight, and ectopic pregnancy
There are plenty of benefits to both choices. Let’s take a look at them.
Benefits of Repeat C-Section:
scheduled birth – easier to have support network and preparations in place
time to prepare a support network for post op
much faster method for emergencies that threaten the life of baby or mom
less liability for the doctor and hospital
Benefits of VBAC:
better immediate bonding with baby (lack of drugs, etc)
better breastfeeding results
avoid major abdominal surgery and all the risks that entails
birth the way God created our bodies to function
much less expensive
less hospital time
fewer complications for mom and baby
Every mama has to weigh these risks and benefits and come to a decision with their partner and an OB they trust. My former OB told me I was a great candidate for VBAC but that she didn’t do them, so I looked to my local ICAN chapter to find recommendations for VBAC friendly OBs in my area. I found an awesome doctor and am so happy with the prenatal care I’ve received. The information that helped me make my decision to try for a VBAC is the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology’s (governing body of OB/GYN) recent statement on VBAC. The most important quote is below and you can find a link to the full statement under the resource links at the bottom of the post.
“The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) and the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) agree that that most women with a history of one or two uncomplicated low transverse caesarean sections, in an otherwise uncomplicated pregnancy at term and with no contraindications to vaginal birth, are candidates for and should be counseled about VBAC.”
If your OB tells you differently, they are going against the policy of their own governing body and you should probably question their motives.
Looking for resources and information about birth, VBAC, and cesarean recovery? Try these:
cant wait to meet your daughter, no matter how she comes into this world. and you sure do nerd out on research!
Thank you for sharing your research. I am a huge advocate of women being educated about their childbirth options and you have definitely done your “homework” and are encouraging other women to better understand their options for giving birth. There are so many medical interventions being done in our country that are simply accepted as safe because they are so common, that women do not realize the risks involved. I am praying for a safe, healthy delivery for your and your sweet baby and that you are able to experience the VBAC you are hoping for. Blessings, Sara (hopesprings designs)
I did the VBAC and I regret the whole thing. I had to have several surgeries after to repair the damage of a long labor and delivery and the epesiotomy. My Dr knew that I would be having a large baby, since my first was 9lb 9oz, he told me that was an average size. My VBAC baby was 10lb 2oz. I will always have issues with the bathroom due to the repository. My recovery from the c section was so much easier!!!
Hey Beth! I’m so sorry you had a bad experience on your VBAC journey. I think cases like your’s are why most OBs are now avoiding episiotomies. Here’s a link that explains more about why episiotomies are bad. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/22/episiotomy-childbirth-guidelines_n_1799394.html I had a 2nd degree tear and the recovery was a still a dream compared with my c-section. I’m so sorry you’ve had to go through so much. I hope you can experience total healing and recovery soon.
Ironically, I came across your blog on Pinterest exactly 25 years after my VBAC, and thought I’d share one more benefit: the psychological healing. My first child was supposed to be a peaceful home birth, but he was 15 days overdue, and posterior, necessitating a C-section. A century earlier, that scenario would have resulted in death for one or both of us. And while intellectually, I knew it was the only choice and was happy making it, there was always a small part of me that felt I had failed in a biological sense–unable to complete that one bodily function, I felt less “womanly.” Having a successful VBAC helped me feel better about me.